Sign in / Join

Sequoia-backed video chat app Tribe spammed its prospects’ tackle books


Can cell app startups please cease constructing SMS invite techniques into their apps already? The most recent instance of a venture-backed startup getting dinged by prospects for having spammed their whole tackle guide with out permission is Sequoia portfolio firm Tribe. The video chat app hit the App Retailer final yr, and had been well-received till now.

With plenty of intelligent twists on commonplace video chat, Tribe itself is an fascinating product. It will possibly add subtitles to video chats and may establish “magic phrases” in conversations which can be then become hyperlinks to the belongings you referred to, like instructions, the climate, a tune, a spot, and extra.

As of October 2016, the app had been downloaded half 1,000,000 instances, and was seeing round 40,000 every day customers. Earlier this yr, it additionally pulled in $three million in seed funding, led by Sequoia, with the intention of difficult dominant chat apps, like Snapchat and Messenger.


But it surely doesn’t take a lot to tarnish a model, and violating customers’ belief is a straightforward technique to lose a following.

In Tribe’s case, its SMS invite system apparently had an “difficulty” – or, no less than, that’s the official rationalization the corporate is telling customers by way of its Twitter account.

In keeping with plenty of Tribe prospects, together with those that posted publicly and reached out privately, the app despatched out SMS invitations to everybody of their tackle books with out permission.

That has resulted in folks – together with those that have been solely listening to of Tribe for the primary time – being spammed with textual content message invitations. And since some victims had multiple pal on Tribe who was affected by the issue, they obtained a number of SMS invitations all through the day.

One person reported having obtained 32 spam invites, for instance, and one other mentioned they obtained as much as 47 invitations in a single day.

Not like different apps up to now, like Ever (beforehand Everalbum), it’s not clear if Tribe used deceptive onboarding screens that tricked customers into inviting everybody of their contacts. That might nonetheless be shady conduct – and the sort that may get you no less than quickly banned from the App Retailer. However some customers are saying they by no means gave the app permission to ask anybody in any respect. This could make Tribe’s glitch not simply an annoyance, but additionally an unlawful one. 

As one tipster advised TechCrunch, they obtained no less than 20 texts from individuals who mentioned they by no means despatched out invitations. Many are additionally saying this on Twitter.

Nonetheless, one other Tribe person identified that the app was pre-selecting all their contacts on a deceptive display screen, which suggests those that spammed their tackle books could have unintentionally given the app permission to take action.

The issue is that you could’t essentially show which is true as a consequence of the truth that some components of an app will be up to date with out having to undergo the App Retailer assessment course of, and it’s doable to A/B check totally different person experiences on the similar time.

In any occasion, persons are indignant:

Tribe’s response to prospects does not embody an evidence of what went mistaken, and even actually, a lot of an apology.

As a substitute, the account is individually tweeting again to affected prospects a imprecise message saying that it “fastened a difficulty on our finish.” In some circumstances the account provides “sorry” to its tweet, however different instances it merely answered with a extra generic reply as an alternative.

“Thanks for the suggestions and we’re all the time searching for methods to enhance the Tribe platform,” the account mentioned in response to a number of the earlier complaints.

Whereas Twitter can’t be used to find out how many individuals have been truly spammed due to this difficulty, a glitch of this nature needs to be trigger for concern. It violates person belief (and presumably, the regulation), so it shouldn’t get to fly below the radar.

At this level, it could be acceptable for Apple to tug the app for a further assessment to make sure the technical repair is in place, because the startup claims.

We’ve reached out to Tribe for remark, however one was not supplied on the time of publication. If the corporate responds, we’ll replace.

Replace, eight:30 PM ET – 

Tribe founder Cyril Paglino responded to say that, yesterday, the corporate up to date its onboarding move and was testing some new advertising and marketing methods.

“We rapidly observed some points with a subset of our customers. The difficulty was solved as quickly because it was dropped at our consideration, in few hours,” he says. “We tooked it very significantly. To be exact, nobody has been spammed because the center of final night time.”

“We by no means need to violate our person’s belief and acutely perceive how important that’s to our group. We extremely worth our person’s privateness, and we all the time need Tribe to be a spot the place you’ll be able to talk safely and securely.”


Leave a reply